zone tool options

Anonymous · ‎2007-12-13

I would love to be able to use the zone tool to provide the length and width of the room I place it in. I think this would be very helpful during the design development stage so that when room sizes change in the model, the length and width automatically changes with it.

Anonymous · ‎2007-12-13

Many of us share your desire. Alas we lack access to the internal parameters that would make automatic dimensions possible. Some of us have added dynamic hotspots for a semi-automatic version (really more of a manual assist) but they involve stretching nodes to fit the room, which then must be adjusted when the room changes. Hopefully GS will give us what we need to do this some time.

TomWaltz · ‎2007-12-13

It's a tricky topic because you have to consider L-shaped rooms or curved rooms. You might not always want just the X-length and Y-length.

Tom Waltz

Djordje · ‎2007-12-14

TomWaltz wrote:
It's a tricky topic because you have to consider L-shaped rooms or curved rooms. You might not always want just the X-length and Y-length.

My feelings exactly.

Area is what is the room sold by ... and dimensions say X Y and whatever is in between

Djordje

ArchiCAD since 4.55 ... 1995
HP Omen

Rakela Raul · ‎2007-12-14

do a search:
there is a zone (by a good samaritan) that gives X and Y dims

MACBKPro /32GiG / 240SSD
AC V6 to V18 - RVT V11 to V16

Anonymous · ‎2007-12-14

Djordje wrote:
TomWaltz wrote:
It's a tricky topic because you have to consider L-shaped rooms or curved rooms. You might not always want just the X-length and Y-length.
My feelings exactly.

Area is what is the room sold by ... and dimensions say X Y and whatever is in between

All true, but I still find that clients want to see the room dimensions before they ask about area.

Anonymous · ‎2007-12-14

Chris wrote:
Djordje wrote:
TomWaltz wrote:
It's a tricky topic because you have to consider L-shaped rooms or curved rooms. You might not always want just the X-length and Y-length.
My feelings exactly.

Area is what is the room sold by ... and dimensions say X Y and whatever is in between
All true, but I still find that clients want to see the room dimensions before they ask about area.

I agree that, despite it's limitations, a function like this would be very handy in schematic phase.

Anonymous · ‎2007-12-14

Rakela wrote:
do a search:
there is a zone (by a good samaritan) that gives X and Y dims

I'm kind of new to this forum so I really do not know how to find this info! Your help would be appreciated

Anonymous · ‎2007-12-14

I understand the concerns about odd shaped rooms but more than anything it starts a relationship that can continue on with the changes that are made throughout the design process. It's our job to explain to the client where the measurements are derived from.

Matthew wrote:
Chris wrote:
Djordje wrote:
My feelings exactly.

Area is what is the room sold by ... and dimensions say X Y and whatever is in between
All true, but I still find that clients want to see the room dimensions before they ask about area.
I agree that, despite it's limitations, a function like this would be very handy in schematic phase.

Anonymous · ‎2007-12-14

Hey Djordje,

Is it possible to move this over to the wish list?

Implementation would require no more than for GS to make available a global variable array that identifies the corners of the zone. This would allow GDL programmers to build the function into their zone stamps. I suspect that some enterprising folks might come up with even more clever ideas once this were available.

Find the next step in your career as a Graphisoft Certified BIM Coordinator!

zone tool options

Still looking?

Browse more topics

See latest solutions

Start a new discussion!